
Today in class we began to have a dialogue about "voice" and "point of view" in writing.
I want to amend my comments somewhat, or extend them, perhaps?
I argued in class that there is no such thing as "authentic voice" and that I disagreed with the book on this point, seeing voice in writing as always an aspect of constructed performance. Of course, then we began a debate about nature v. nurture (biological determinism v. social construction). I maintain my position on this issue: we can never completely remove ourselves enough from our own cultural baggage to see nature through some pure lens. We always see through a cultural lens. So nature and nurture are inseparable. We cannot understand nature without culture. Or to put it another way, we have invented culture to understand our nature (but then where was the starting point? Chicken or egg? Impossible to determine, I would think).
Another strand of the argument went along the lines of voice being recognizable in print as identical to one's speaking voice. I would agree with the recognizable part and disagree with the identical part. To take an analogical leap: As a younger person I took voice lessons. I have a naturally high voice with little vibrato. This is a matter of biology. The fact that I am classified as a soprano is a matter of cultural interpretation. By taking voice lessons, I was able to increase my range, my volume, my lung capacity, and the quality of clearness in my voice. Additionally, if I were to sing different parts in different musicals, I may be called upon to use my voice in different styles of singing, making more or less use of my nasal passages etc. As I've gotten older, my voice has lowered slightly, and probably will continue to do so. If I go without singing for a long time, all of the advances I made in vocal training whither away. My voice is never just one note. It changes over time and according to the demands of performance. However, it remains recognizable qualitatively as my voice. I will never be a baritone, no matter how much I train. Is this analogous to writing? You tell me.
One more amendment: the metaphorical concept of "finding a voice" or "coming to voice" is still powerful, despite my belief that there is no authentic voice. For those who have felt silenced (orally or in writing), the opportunity to express one's own opinions in a distinctive and subjective style is liberating. Voice is a good metaphor for such a process.
I was unable to blog at my conference, as you know, because internet access in my room cost 15$ a day! Here are a few observations about the culture I observed there. Of course, there were many subcultures. They were defined by age, areas of scholarship, institutional affiliations, if you had the money to pay for internet access.... One overarching observation across the subcultures (but at varying degrees) was an atmosphere of both competitiveness and amicable scholarly sharing. So, typically after a panel, there would be pretty friendly questions from the audience, but there would also be some sense of disagreement or challenge often. This makes for friendly, but tense relations, it seems to me.
I went to a "rock and roll dance party" on Saturday night and enjoyed watching different generations of scholars and students wash onto and off of the dance floor as the music switched from ABBA to Madonna to the Violent Femmes to Lady Gaga. I was surprised to see some scholars I know and consider quite serious shaking it on the dance floor. It was like a window into some other part of their souls--a loose, sensuous side.
I also got to participate in an open poetry reading, which I found particularly satisfying personally, since my Masters is in creative writing--poetry. I enjoyed finding other misfit poets among the rhetoricians and compositionists.
That's all I have for now. If I could have blogged on site, perhaps I'd paint a particular picture for you, but alas, I've lost them all.
Remember for Thursday:
- Respond to your partner's blog.
- Rewrite your paragraph (from in class response to Box 9) in a new voice or point of view and be prepared to share it next time.
- Do the IRB training at the "research" page on OU's website (just search "research") and create a consent form for future interviews.
- Do the groundwork activity p. 166.
See you Thu.